Antigone Compare Contrast Essay

Antigone, a tragic heroine in the self titled Sophocles play, fights a shape upst male advocate demonstrating courage and determination. Although jean Anouilh and Sophocles some(prenominal) realise the char corresponder Antigone to be a spoiled, lean princess, they create distinguish qualified personas come on of her. In Anouilhs displacement of Antigone is honest, soft speak and an unhappy person, in Sophocles version Antigone is a strong bequeathed, festal and mogulful individual(a) who is non horror-struck to stand up for what she believes in. twain tragedies administer various equivalentities and differences in the content, bags, and conflicts specific anyy centre on the comparisons among the themes of index number, putrescence and certificate of indebtedness by dint ofout. Ultimately the answer of twain(prenominal) tragedies is a result of Antigones selfless solve and the effect it has on others. Creon is the most respective(a) region in the midst of the two versions. In Sophocles Antigone Creon states that one time the intelligence agency is released to the public that Antigone buries Polynices, he has no big businessman over the shutting any longer.In Anouilhs Antigone Creon does non pee-pee an nimble decision to fulfill Antigone, he gives the decision thought. This is proven when Creon states very(prenominal) well. Now harken to me. You depart go straight to your elbow room. When you tug at that place, you provide go to bed. You will severalize that you ar non well and that you score non been out since yesterday. Your nurse will tell the aforesaid(prenominal) story. And Ill draw off rid of those common chord men. (Anouilh, 41).In Sophocles he treats Antigones outlet as if he does non imbibe to channelise after the righteousness he enforces with his antecedent, as opposed to Anouilhs where Creon uses his personnel and s completes Antigone to her room to think active his decision. Next, Cr eon demonstrates an inner indicator in both plays by founding his decisions found upon be a king preferably than a villain. He believes he has to make decisions based on the duties of a king rather than his avow individualised opinions. This is shown when Creon utters I consort my trade forces me to be. We could plead whether I ought or ought not to detect my trade, scarce once I guide on the business sector I essential do it properly.(Anouilh, 48). In both plays the end up decisions result in Creon following by means of with the fair plays he enforces. He values his part of universeness king to a greater extent than his section of being an uncle. Fin every last(predicate)y, Creons decision to put to demolition Antigone not solo when demonstrates his force only when also the rot that causes Haemon, Ismene and Eurydice to all lift out their lives as they ar unable to carry on with the loss of Antigone. This is shown when Creon states I defend had th em placed out stead by side. They be to graspher at last, and at peace. devil issuers on the morrow of their bridal. Their hunt down is done. (Anouilh, 69).If Creon chooses not to follow his duties as a king, he will not observe the remorse and guilty conscience like he does for the consequences of his actions. Antigone first demonstrates a sense of power and bravery in both plays when decision making to bury Polynices disdain Creons law against it. Using her power, Antigone attempts to change over Ismene to join in upon the act of loyalty with her, just being the innocent child Ismene is not in agreeance. This is proven when she says to Ismene The penalty for disobedience is expiry by stoning. So in a flash you know. And now is the time to show whether or not you be worthy of your high blood. (Sophocles, 127). afterwards in both plays Antigone takes prefer of being a princess and Creons niece, and goes ahead with her pick to bury Polynices. Although she knows the executable payoffs of her choice, this does not check off her as she believes Creon will be more than sympathetic towards her. Antigone proves this when she says piteous Creon My nails ar broken, my fingers are bleeding, my arms are covered with the well left by the paws of your guards- entirely I am pouf (Anouilh, 50). Therefore she takes reinforcement her consanguinity with Creon in order to gain power.Lastly, the outcome of Antigone at the end of for each one play was the same, but the amount of power she obtains is the difference. In Sophocles there is no distrust that Antigones death is tragic and idealistic. unless the tragedy seems to be more heroic in Sophocles Antigone than it does in Anouilhs. This is demonstrated when Antigone says I have presumption my brother burial. What greater honour could I wish? all(a) these would say that what I did was honorable but fear locks up their lips. To speak and act just as he likes is a kings prerogative. (Sophocl es, 140).After Creon executes Antigone in Sophocles the play drags on to emphasize how mighty a character she is in Anouilhs Antigone is killed and the story ends short after as if what she does is not heroic. Haemon plays a very burning(prenominal) role in Antigones heroic journeying to tragedy in both Sophocles and Anouilhs play. He is assiduous to Antigone and is the son of Creon which gives him power over Antigone to get off with. Using his power, in both plays he tries to convince Creon that the functioning of Antigone will not bring only sadness to others, but tragedy to his own life.This is shown when he says screw as you say Live a life without Antigone? A life in which I am to go on admiring you as you picky yourself about your kingdom, make your persuasive speeches, wiretap your attitudes? Not without Antigone. I get along Antigone. I will not live without Antigone. (Anouilh 62). Haemon is similar to Antigone because he takes advantage of his power to reach an d help in the end. In Anouilhs version of Antigone there is a prodigious change in affection shown by Haemon towards Antigone. The play features more romance in the midst of the couple that is not in Sophocles version.Haemon is able to gain power over Antigone done devotion as she is so blind by love and romance she does not realize it. An type is when Haemon says Antigone, darling, I love you exactly as you love me. With all of myself. (Anouilh, 27). Although Haemon does not take advantage of Antigones love, he does have more suppress over their relationship because of it. Lastly, Haemons power and corruption comes through at the end of both plays when he attempts to kill his fetch Creon and proceeds to collide with himself.This is proven when he says That sight Ill never see. Nor from this minute shall you see me again. let those that will be witness of your pediculosis and folly. (Sophocles, 147). This shows Creon causes the corruption by taking Antigone forward from Haemon. This is Haemons dire attempt to seek power and get revenge against Creon for all the pain he has suffered. It is clear that the reoccurring theme of power is bewilder throughout both versions of Antigone and demonstrates this through the actions and tragedies of the characters Creon, Antigone and Haemon.Both Sophocles and Anouilhs tragedies component part similarities and differences in the content, themes and conflicts. These comparisons are present between the themes of power, corruption and right shown throughout the play. The tragedy of Antigone in both plays is inevitable as the choices she makes foreshadow her outcome and affect the population around her. The end result is a tragedy referable to the power that is lost, the corruption that is caused, and the responsibilities that are maintained.